There's more to a company's performance than just its stock price. Know more about it here!
| From the desk of Miles Everson: Hi! Welcome to today’s edition of “Return Driven Strategy (RDS).” For those of you who don’t know yet, RDS is a pyramid-shaped framework with 11 tenets and 3 foundations. When applied properly, these principles help businesses achieve their organizational objectives. Today, let’s delve deeper into the 3rd foundation of RDS ( Disciplined Performance Measurement and Valuation). Are you ready? Keep reading below to know more. |
|
There's more to a company's performance than just its stock price. Know more about it here! Do you think we can rely on stock price as the ultimate indicator of company performance? According to Professor Joel Litman and Dr. Mark L. Frigo in the book, “Driven,” for many reasons, the answer is NO. Huh? Why is that so? It’s because most companies don’t have publicly traded stock to look at. Besides, there are literally millions of businesses in the U.S. that do not have a traded stock price. However, an understanding of what drives stock price valuations has a lasting impact for business managers of private companies as well. What’s more? Professor Litman and Dr. Frigo say that even though the largest and most well-known companies in the world have stock prices to examine, a fundamental misunderstanding of stock pricing can still persist. What Drives Stock Market Valuations According to Professor Litman and Dr. Frigo, managers express as much confusion about stock price as there appear to be misconceptions about strategy. In fact, CEOs of publicly-traded firms often lament the seeming disconnect between “valuation” and “reality.” Here are some of the things they say: “The market doesn’t understand my company.” “We honestly have no idea what makes our company stock price go up or down. Sales are up. We thought showing large increases in net income would be good. But our stock price hasn’t moved.” “My competitors have higher valuations. But everyone and their mother know that we are a better run, better-built company. So, I’d rather not have my employees focus on our stock price. It’s distracting more than anything else.” Here’s the thing: There’s a difference between a “great company” and a “great stock.” If you want to know what distinguishes one from the other, one of the things you need to be clear about is the difference between performance and valuation. Simply said: Performance - Historical and focuses on what the company has done. Valuation - About the future, about hope, and about a company’s prospects and forecasts. Let’s take a look at these examples… Professor Litman and Dr. Frigo agree that Coca-Cola (KO) provides a great example that brings the above point home.
In mid-1998, KO’s stock price traded at an incredible high of USD 88 per share. Eight years later, the company’s stock price stood at about half of that mark—USD 44. Woah, what happened? Could Coca-Cola have lost its incredible competitive advantages? Did falling valuation imply poor performance? In spite of these valuation issues, Coca-Cola continued to generate Uniform ROAs at some of the highest levels of all earning power seen across more than 5,000 companies. So, what’s the problem with KO? According to Professor Litman and Dr. Frigo, applying Return Driven Strategy’s (RDS) disciplined performance measurement and valuation implies a skill for deciphering the following problem: Business profitability levels, as well as stock returns that often seem to be greatly out of sync and even totally disconnected. The problem was not that KO had not achieved incredible performance. The problem was a question as to whether that performance was sustainable . The disconnect between KO’s stock price and performance occurred not because the company isn’t a great one; it occurred because the stock’s valuation in 1998 was at the level of being fairly unjustifiable. See? According to Professor Litman and Dr. Frigo, great stock prices and great companies can accompany each other, but one needs to examine sufficiently long time periods . Meanwhile, Ames Department Stores ’ stock price run from 1996 to 2000 was “incredible.” Through that period, its shares rose more than tenfold, and investors and management seemed as happy as can be.
Unfortunately, the epilogue of this retailer is described too sadly by a string of empty buildings and emptier parking lots in strip malls across the Northeastern United States. By 2001, the firm had already been seeking bankruptcy protection. How could posted company performance and actual company stock price send such different messages? Here’s the thing: At Ames, investor forecasts simply exceeded reality. The original march upward from lows of USD 2 in 1996 to USD 30 and higher was not because the company was incredibly profitable. It was because Ames began avidly restructuring, divesting its least-performing assets. According to Professor Litman and Dr. Frigo, when a firm expected to go bankrupt doesn’t go bankrupt , its stock price rises, sometimes by leaps and bounds. Ames’ closure shows the folly of a management team that does not understand the real drivers of stock price. Growing a bad business is always a bad thing , no matter how well the stock price is doing. Ames’s death came relatively quickly, as its share price fell fast, and the chain finally closed for good in late 2002. See? That’s why Professor Litman and Dr. Frigo say great stocks aren’t often great companies and vice versa! According to them, one must have a comprehensive understanding of the connection between strategy, execution, performance, and valuation. Besides, rigorous performance measurement is necessary for understanding TRUE business performance! In their words: “Without this foundation, it would be impossible to truly discern good companies from bad ones, or worthy activities from poor ones. With a thorough understanding of performance measures and valuation, an entire framework for business planning can be built.” If you’re looking to gain a better understanding of Return Driven Strategy and Career Driven Strategy, we highly recommend checking out “Driven” by Professor Litman and Dr. Frigo. Click here to get your copy and learn how this framework can help you in your business strategies and ultimately, in ethically maximizing wealth for your firm. Hope you found this week’s insights interesting and helpful.
Stay tuned for next Tuesday’s Return Driven Strategy! This company has been associated with the PC manufacturing space for years. Due to this, it has been flying under the radar, as some have written off its value generation due to assumptions about it being a pure play PC manufacturer. Learn more about the importance of pivoting in the world of business in next week’s article! |
Miles Everson
CEO of MBO Partners and former Global Advisory and Consulting CEO at PwC, Everson has worked with many of the world's largest and most prominent organizations, specializing in executive management. He helps companies balance growth, reduce risk, maximize return, and excel in strategic business priorities.
He is a sought-after public speaker and contributor and has been a case study for success from Harvard Business School.
Everson is a Certified Public Accountant, a member of the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants and Minnesota Society of Certified Public Accountants. He graduated from St. Cloud State University with a B.S. in Accounting.
